Best Harmonicas for Beginners: Five Dependable Choices
Five dependable diatonic harmonicas for beginners compared by comb, reeds, tone and upkeep, with advice on choosing the right one for you.
A good first harmonica does one thing above all: it gets out of your way. It should be airtight enough that single notes and bends come without a struggle, comfortable enough to play every day and sturdy enough to survive a learner's heavy breath. This guide compares five well-established diatonic harmonicas that meet that standard.
All five are 10-hole diatonic harmonicas in standard Richter tuning. Buy whichever you choose in the key of C; our guide to which key to buy first explains why.
How we chose
We looked for instruments that are:
- made by long-established manufacturers;
- available in all keys, so you can add to your set later;
- held together with screws where possible, so they can be cleaned;
- widely available from UK music shops and online retailers.
We have left out the very cheapest harmonicas. Toy-grade instruments leak air, and a leaky harmonica is much harder to learn on.
We do not quote prices, because they change. As a rule, the instruments below are listed roughly from the least to the most expensive within each maker's range, and all sit in the "serious student" bracket.
Comparison table
| Harmonica | Comb | Reeds | Covers | Character | Stand-out feature |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hohner Special 20 | Plastic, recessed plates | Brass | Closed sides | Warm, mellow | The standard teacher recommendation |
| Lee Oskar Major Diatonic | Plastic, recessed plates | Brass | Closed sides | Bright, clear | Replaceable reed plates |
| Hohner Rocket | Plastic, rounded | Brass | Open sides | Loud, bright | Comfort and volume |
| Seydel Session Steel | Plastic, recessed plates | Stainless steel | Wide back opening | Bright, sustained | Long-lasting steel reeds |
| Hohner Marine Band 1896 | Pearwood | Brass | Open sides | Bright, traditional | The classic blues sound |
1. Hohner Special 20
Best for: most beginners.
The plastic comb with recessed reed plates gives a smooth mouthpiece and an airtight instrument that needs almost no looking after. Its tone is warm and slightly mellow. If you want a safe choice and do not wish to think further, this is it.
Read our Hohner Special 20 review
2. Lee Oskar Major Diatonic
Best for: learners who want low running costs.
Similar in concept to the Special 20, with slightly larger holes and one great practical advantage: when the reeds wear out you can fit new reed plates for less than the cost of a new harmonica. It is tuned for accurate single-note melody playing.
Read our Lee Oskar Major Diatonic review
3. Hohner Rocket
Best for: playing with other people.
A close relative of the Special 20 with open-sided covers and a rounded comb. It is louder and brighter, which helps when you play unamplified alongside guitars, and it is very comfortable to hold.
4. Seydel Session Steel
Best for: those who will play a great deal.
Stainless steel reeds are designed to last longer than brass. The Session Steel costs more, but for a keen player who practises daily it can be a sound investment. The hole spacing is a little wider than on other makes.
Read our Seydel Session Steel review
5. Hohner Marine Band 1896
Best for: lovers of the traditional sound.
The original blues harp, with a pearwood comb and a bright, open voice. It needs more care than the others, and its nailed construction makes it harder to service, so we suggest it as a second harmonica for most learners. If its sound is the reason you took up the instrument, though, there is no substitute.
Read our Hohner Marine Band 1896 review
Which should you choose?
- You want the simplest answer: Hohner Special 20.
- You want to keep costs down over the years: Lee Oskar Major Diatonic.
- You will play acoustically in a group: Hohner Rocket.
- You practise every day and money is less of a concern: Seydel Session Steel.
- You want the sound of classic blues records: Hohner Marine Band 1896.
Any of the five will take you from your first note to an advanced level. The differences between them matter far less than regular practice.
What about cheaper harmonicas?
There are respectable harmonicas at lower prices, and they are a reasonable way to find out whether you enjoy the instrument. Look for a recognised maker, a plastic comb and screws, and avoid anything sold as a toy or in a multi-pack of every key for the price of one good harmonica.
After you buy
Filed under: Reviews Buying Guides